How do I tell if a Goody Beanie Baby is real?

Style number. The tush tag and the inside of the swing tag should both read style 40275. A mismatch between the two tags is one of the most common fake tells. Tag print quality. Genuine swing tags are printed on stiff, glossy card with crisp edges on the star and clean, evenly spaced type. Fuzzy edges, bleeding ink, or type that sits at a slight angle are reprint tells. Tush tag. Check the font weight and spacing, the position of the ® and ™ marks, and that the stated country of manufacture is one Ty actually used for this era. Documented errors only. Tag misspellings are only valuable when they are a known, documented Ty error. An undocumented 'error' is far more likely to be a counterfeiter's mistake than a find.

Beanie Reference

Goody the Beanie Baby Value & Tag Guide

Everything on file for Goody the Beanie Baby: release facts, the swing-tag generations it can legitimately carry, what to inspect before you believe it's genuine, and every completed sale we have documented — with the date and condition attached.

What is the Goody Beanie Baby worth?

Across 8 documented sales, Goody has a median completed-sale price of $14.69. Individual sales ran from $9.75 to $18.89, driven by tag generation, condition and variation.

Based on completed sales only — prices buyers actually paid, not asking prices. Most recent documented sale: October 18, 2026.

Release facts

Animal: Bear
Category: Bears
Introduced: Not recorded
Ty style number: 40275
Ty birth date: Not recorded
Catalogue: Expanded Ty roster

Documented sold prices

These are completed sales — what buyers paid — recorded from eBay completed listings and stored with their sale date so the history accumulates instead of rolling off.

Documented sales

Median

$14.69

Lowest

$9.75

Highest

$18.89

Documented completed sales of the Goody Beanie Baby
Sold	Price	Condition	Format	Listing title
Oct 18, 2026	$17.99	new	Buy It Now	Ty Beanie Baby GOODY the Gingerbread Man 6.5" NEW MWMTs Plush Stuffed Animal ToyListing ↗ · Photo ↗
Sep 23, 2026	$12.89

How to spot a fake Goody

Style number. The tush tag and the inside of the swing tag should both read style 40275. A mismatch between the two tags is one of the most common fake tells.
Tag print quality. Genuine swing tags are printed on stiff, glossy card with crisp edges on the star and clean, evenly spaced type. Fuzzy edges, bleeding ink, or type that sits at a slight angle are reprint tells.
Tush tag. Check the font weight and spacing, the position of the ® and ™ marks, and that the stated country of manufacture is one Ty actually used for this era.
Documented errors only. Tag misspellings are only valuable when they are a known, documented Ty error. An undocumented 'error' is far more likely to be a counterfeiter's mistake than a find.
Construction. Seams should be machine-stitched, tight and even, with symmetric eye and nose placement and no glue. Loose or glued features are a strong fake signal.
Fabric and color. Over-bright, over-fuzzy, or plasticky fabric on a supposed 1990s release usually means a modern reproduction.

Checks that need the item in hand are exactly what our authentication process performs. More background in the rarity guide and beanie info.

Own a Goody?

Have it authenticated and list it here — every sale is escrow-protected, and every authenticated item carries a sealed COA and a permanent BX Registry number.

Authenticate a Beanie Sell Your Beanies Browse the Marketplace

Reference values are collector estimates; documented sale prices come from recorded completed eBay listings. Not affiliated with Ty Inc. or eBay. Beanie Babies® and Ty® are trademarks of their respective owner. Back to the full Beanie Baby database.